You are here

Locking the Detect Edges Tonal Sample in Aperture 3

Scott Davenport's picture
July 25, 2014 - 12:00pm

Brushes and Detect Edges

Edge detection can be turned on for all of Aperture's adjustment brushes with the “Detect Edges” checkbox. Edge detection is based on tonality differences in your photo. As you brush an adjustment in or out, Aperture samples the tone at the crosshairs of the brush and applies or removes the adjustment only to those areas similar in tonality. If the crosshairs of the brush enter a new tonal range, a sample is taken and the new range is affected too.

For example, a right-to-left swipe crossing tonal boundaries applies the adjustment to the sky and the street pole.

Detect Edges continually samples tonality at the brush crosshairs

The crosshairs of the brush touched both the sky and the street pole in this right-to-left swipe of the brush. As the crosshairs entered the street pole, Aperture sampled the tone of the concrete and applied the adjustment. When the crosshairs returned to the sky, Aperture detected another tone and applied the adjustment to the sky again.

The Shift-click Trick

You can have Aperture lock the edge detection tonal sample by holding down the Shift key. This works with any adjustment that can be brushed in. Select “Detect Edges”, hold down the Shift key, click the brush crosshairs on the area of your photo you want the adjustment to affect, and begin brushing. Once you start brushing, you can release the Shift key.

The Shift-click turns off Aperture's continuous tonal sampling. Even if the brush crosshairs hover over a different tonal range, only ranges matching the spot you first clicked are affected by the adjustment. For example, a Shift-click in the sky and a swipe from right-to-left only applied the adjustment to the sky. The street pole, being a different tonal range than the initial sample area, the sky, is not affected.

Shift Happens

Adjustments to large, uniform tonal areas such as skies can be quickly and accurately applied using “Detect Edges” and Shift-click. In this example, I adjusted the entire sky with a Shift-click in the sky followed by insanely broad brush strokes across the top of the image. Since I locked the tonal range, the adjustment only affected the sky.

Quickly apply adjustments to large, uniform areas by locking the edge detection tonal range

Using the Shift key to lock the tonal sample also works well when the tonal ranges at edges are very similar. The human eye can see edges with more accuracy than sampling algorithms. The next time you're applying an adjustment and edge detection isn't working precisely, it may be because the tonal differences at the edges are too narrow. Give the Shift key a go. You may be pleasantly surprised.

About the author, Scott Davenport:

I'm a San Diego based landscape photographer and can't get enough of the ocean. Good natured, secretly shy, and much more comfortable behind the camera than in front of it.

I have authored several photography books and videos. My latest products are Removing Distractions From Your Photos (video), 10 Tips For Photographing Beautiful Seascapes (eBook) and Migrating From Aperture to Lightroom (FREE!). You can see my work at

Adjustments Detect Edges Brushes
Apple Aperture
Scott Davenport

Geez Scott, I didn’t know this tip! Thanks! Will give it a try. Should be much better than continually shifting back and forth from “detect edges” :)

I’ve been using brushes for years and didn’t know about this.  Thanks Scott.  memo to self: RTFM!

Andrew Macnaughton

Great Tip - Am using it already. Better, easier, faster… Makes me wonder, what else can I learn… Thanks for sharing ;-)


Great Tip - Am using it already. Better, easier, faster… Makes me wonder, what else can I learn… Thanks for sharing ;-)


Thank you! Very valuable tip. I’ve never heard of this before.

Paul C

You may login with either your assigned username or your e-mail address.
Passwords are case-sensitive - Forgot your password?

Or log in with...

© 2015 PhotosApps.Expert All rights reserved.